Elsevier

Nurse Education Today

Volume 59, December 2017, Pages 66-74
Nurse Education Today

Review
Widening participation in nurse education: An integrative literature review,☆☆

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2017.08.016Get rights and content

Highlights

  • The nursing workforce needs to reflect the diversity of the population.

  • Widening participation is a mechanism to enable this to occur.

  • There are minimal studies exploring widening participation in nursing.

  • Nurse educators and the profession need a strategic focus on widening participation.

  • Changes to funding nurse education (UK) could impact upon widening participation.

Abstract

Background

Widening participation into higher education is espoused within educational policy in the UK, and internationally, as a mechanism to promote equality and social mobility. As nurse education is located within higher education it has a responsibility to promote widening participation within pre-registration educational programmes. It could also be argued that the profession has a responsibility to promote equality to ensure its' workforce is as diverse as possible in order to best address the health needs of diverse populations.

Objectives

To undertake an integrative review on published papers exploring Widening Participation in undergraduate, pre-registration nurse education in the UK.

Design

A six step integrative review methodology was utilised, reviewing papers published in English from 2013–2016.

Data Sources

Search of CINAHL, Education Source, MEDLINE, PsychINFO, SocINDEX, Science Direct, Business Source Complete, ERIC, British Library ETOS, Teacher Reference Centre, Informit Health Collection and Informit Humanities and Social Science Collection which highlighted 449 citations; from these 14 papers met the review inclusion criteria.

Review Methods

Both empirical studies and editorials focusing upon widening participation in pre-registration nurse education in the UK (2013–2016) were included. Papers excluded were non UK papers or papers not focussed upon widening participation in pre-registration nursing education. Research papers included in the review were assessed for quality using appropriate critical appraisal tools.

Results

14 papers were included in the review; these were analysed thematically identifying four themes; knowledge and identification of WP, pedagogy and WP, attrition and retention and career prospects.

Conclusions

Whilst widening participation is a key issue for both nurse education and the wider profession there is a lack of conceptualisation and focus regarding mechanisms to both encourage and support a wider diversity of entrant. Whilst there are some studies, these focus on particular individual widening participation groups rather than a wider strategic focus across the student lifecycle.

Introduction

Widening participation (WP) into Higher Education is an international concern (Bowes et al., 2013, Shah et al., 2016). It is essentially concerned with increasing the numbers of people from underrepresented groups attending Higher Education. Whilst particular target groups differ internationally some commonalities exist, for example, mature or second chance learner, students with disabilities, students from black or ethnic minority groups and from lower socioeconomic backgrounds (Thomas and Quinn, 2003). In England, the commitment to WP is demonstrated in the national strategy ‘Access and student success in higher education’ (Department for Business Innovation and Skills, 2014, p. 3), which asserts: ‘…anyone with the potential to succeed in Higher Education should have the equal opportunity to do so’. Nomenclature differs between countries, for example (National Centre for student equity in higher education, 2017) in the United Kingdom, the phrase widening participation is used, whereas in Australia the preferred term is equity; at the heart of both of these is a commitment to increase opportunities and outcomes for groups which traditionally have limited access to Higher Education and the associated benefits. However it has to be remembered that Widening Participation (and equivalent concepts) is not just concerned with access to Higher education, but also success in higher education and beyond, including completion, attainment and progression to employment and/or post graduate study (Higher Education Funding Council for England, 2013).

Reasons for the drive to increase the diversity of the student population are multi-faceted, with benefits to individuals, the HE community and society (Department for Business Innovation and Skills, 2014). Graduates have greater job security, increased financial well-being and better physical and mental health. Greater diversity within higher education also enriches learning, promoting values such as equality and tolerance and diversifying the social and cultural environment (Shaw et al., 2007). While for society WP promotes social mobility and societal economic and cultural growth (Department for Business Innovation and Skills, 2014). Social Mobility relates to the ability of individuals to move their social status, education is key mechanism of social mobility as it changes individuals and groups social status through greater financial stability.

Before we explore WP in nursing, we need to define what we mean by ‘nursing’. Within the nursing workforce there are unregistered but trained nursing assistants and associates, however for the context of this paper the word ‘nurse’ and ‘nursing’ refers to individuals who have a registered nursing qualification with the Nursing and Midwifery Council, the UK nursing regulatory body. The nursing profession constitutes the largest professional group within the NHS, and as such it is a key group to consider with regards to WP in healthcare services.

As the majority of educational programmes for nursing professions are located within higher education, these courses contribute to the educational sector's responsibility for WP. However there is also responsibility of the professions to diversify the workforce to meet the needs of the communities they work with. For example, the indigenous population in Australia experiences stark health inequalities (Stewart et al., 2016); health care professionals working in these communities have not been effective in addressing health inequalities for a number of reasons one being cultural differences. This has resulted in the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Accreditation Council asserting that nurse education programmes have to include education on indigenous health and culture (Australian Nursing and Midwifery Accreditation Council, 2012). This has promoted targeted recruitment and training of indigenous health workers to work within their local community (Kumar et al., 2015). Within Europe, the UK National Health Service (NHS) is the largest employer yet the diversity of the current workforce is not representative of the general population (Health Education England, 2014). Widening Participation is not only important for patient care; it is also a fundamental mechanism to address workforce issues within the profession. There are concerns regarding nursing numbers (Department of Health, 2010). There is an international nurse shortage, due to both an ageing workforce as well as a reduction in the numbers of young people entering the profession (Marangozov et al., 2016), and the global mobility of nurses.

During the 21st century nursing sustained a strong record for recruiting and training a diverse population of students (Royal College of Nursing, 2008), but completion rates have been lower than in other subjects (Woodfield, 2014) and for specific groups: for example males and students born outside of the United Kingdom (Mulholland et al., 2008), highlighting that there is still more work needed to truly widen participation into nursing. A literature review undertaken on WP on health care programmes (Kaehne et al., 2014), found that the evidence base about WP is limited, and studies tend to be small and often single site. There have been no published reviews which have specifically explored WP in nurse educational programmes. Where there has been targeted work this has be within the field of gender — increasing the numbers of males accessing nursing (Mauritius, Hollup, 2014 and Australia, Weaver et al., 2013). Other research has been undertaken specifically about students with disabilities, focusing on supporting disabled students already enrolled on nursing programme rather than WP per se (in the United Kingdom, Salkeld, 2016, Morris and Turnball, 2006, Australia, Azzopardi et al., 2013, Canada, Ashcroft and Lutfiyya, 2013, Japan, Ikematsu et al., 2014, Ireland, Evans, 2014, Howlin et al., 2014a, Howlin et al., 2014b). Health Education England who are responsible for ensuring the healthcare workforce have the right skills have developed their own WP strategy (Health Education England, 2014) cementing the professional commitment to WP. One of their priorities is to increase the understanding of what works and does not work in relation to WP and healthcare education. This paper highlights and contributes to this agenda. The research question that framed the review was: To what degree is widening participation embedded in nurse education? The aim is to provide an integrative review of published papers on WP in undergraduate, pre-registration nursing students in the United Kingdom.

Section snippets

Review Methods

An integrative review methodology was chosen as it enables the inclusion of empirical papers as well as data gained from theoretical and conceptual papers (Tavares de Souza et al., 2010) thus enabling a comprehensive examination of WP in nursing in the United Kingdom.

Findings

This section shall firstly present some reflections on the study characteristics of the papers included in the review before continuing to explore each of the four themes identified (knowledge and identification of WP, pedagogy and WP, attrition and retention, and career prospects).

Discussion

We now return to the question that framed the review ‘to what degree is widening participation embedded in nurse education?’ It is evident that WP is a key issue for nursing, firstly to ensure that it recruits a diverse workforce that is representative and able to meet the healthcare needs of a diverse population. Secondly it is a key recruitment strategy for the profession, due to an international shortage of nurses and an ageing workforce. Despite this, WP is not really integrated into nurse

Conclusion

Widening participation is a key issue for the nursing profession to address. Historically nursing has been successful in recruiting from a diverse base, but the policy context is changing and a strategic vision is required for the profession to ensure that it continues to attract, recruit and educate those from diverse backgrounds. It is of paramount importance that both nursing education providers and clinical nurses begin to have a more strategic understanding of and focus on WP across the

References (53)

  • Y. Ikematsu et al.

    Nursing students with special educational needs in Japan

    Nurse Educ. Pract.

    (2014)
  • M. Kiernan et al.

    The juggling act: do student nurses who care for dependants need an adapted course? An applied policy research study

    Nurse Educ. Today

    (2015)
  • K. Kumar et al.

    Rural and remote young people's health careers decision making within a health workforce development programme: a qualitative exploration

    Rural Remote Health

    (2015)
  • S. McKendry et al.

    Why here and why stay? Students' voices on the retention strategies of a widening participation university'

    Nurse Educ. Today

    (2014)
  • A. Ooms et al.

    Providing learning support to nursing students: a study of two universities

    Nurse Educ. Pract.

    (2013)
  • N. Sharples

    An exploration of deaf women's access to mental health nurse education in the United Kingdom

    Nurse Educ. Today

    (2013)
  • J. Stewart et al.

    Aboriginal and Torres Strait islander health: accuracy of patient self-report of screening for diabetes, high cholesterol and cervical cancer

    Aust. N. Z. J. Public Health

    (2016)
  • Australian Nursing and Midwifery Accreditation Council

    Registered nurse accreditation standards

  • T. Azzopardi et al.

    Simulation as a learning strategy: supporting undergraduate nursing students with disabilities

    J. Clin. Nurs.

    (2013)
  • L. Bowes et al.

    International Research on the Effectiveness of Widening Participation Report to HEFCE and OFFA Edgehill

    (2013)
  • M.J. Brimble

    Does entry route really affect academic outcome? Academic achievement of traditional versus non traditional entrants to BN (Hons) pre-registration nursing programmes

    J. Furth. High. Educ.

    (2015)
  • Centre for Reviews and Dissemination

    Systematic Reviews: CRDs Guidance for Undertaking Reviews in Health Care

    (2009)
  • Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP)

    CASP Tools and Checklists

  • Department for Business, Innovation and Skills

    National Strategy for Access and Student Success in Higher Education

    (2014)
  • Department of Health

    Widening Participation in Pre-registration Nursing Programmes

    (2010)
  • W. Evans

    I am not a dyslexic person I'm a person with dyslexia: identity constructed of dyslexia among students in nurse education

    J. Adv. Nurs.

    (2014)
  • Cited by (0)

    We wish to acknowledge Jan Hutt Academic Support Librarian (Bournemouth University) for her support in conducting the initial search.

    ☆☆

    This work was part of a larger study funded by Bournemouth and Edge Hill Universities.

    View full text